Collection and Retention of Electronic Data: What Every Business Owner, Manager, and HR Professional Needs to Know
By Michael Goldfarb
A client recently asked a question about an email she got advertising ''New Rules for E-Discovery: How to Find Your Blind Spots and Reduce Exposure.'' She wanted to know if she should be concerned about these new rules with respect to the collection and retention of electronic data collected by her business.
Act Now! Activate a FREE three days trial to HRCrossing.com, because you know how important it is to know about all the jobs.
Due to the proliferation of electronic data in everyday business, the federal laws have been amended to meet the challenges of requesting such information during the course of litigation. Parties to litigation acquire information from each other through the process of discovery, generally through the use of such tools as "requests for production of documents" or "subpoenas." While businesses have to be aware of what might be sought during the course of litigation and the consequences of failing to comply with such a request, there is no need to alter your entire way of storing data because of the rule amendments.
Essentially, the amendments are designed to give guidance on how the discovery of electronic data is to be handled and not so much on what particular types of data a company must retain. Having said that, what you need to keep in mind are several rules of thumb in terms of what to save versus what can routinely be deleted:
Any data you are currently required to maintain in paper form must also be retained if collected in electronic form
Any electronic data pertaining to an employee who has filed a claim or lawsuit and which data was not routinely deleted prior to the filing of the claim or suit must be retained
Any electronic data not routinely deleted must be retained
Any data routinely deleted and not mandated by state or federal law to be retained may be deleted.
Here is a brief history of the electronic stored information amendments to the federal code of civil procedure. My suggestion is keep these tips in mind, share them with your IT personnel, the principles of the company, management and your HR department, and convert them into company policy. By using such an approach your company should be more than able to deal with any discovery demand thrown at you in the event of litigation. A lot of what you must retain versus delete is common sense. Always keep that in mind. To that end, the "Safe Harbor" provisions laid out below will provide you with solid guidelines.
Background of Amendments
The Advisory Committee on Civil Rules began analyzing the problem of e-discovery in the 90s and published its proposed amendments in 2004. After some changes, the amendments were approved by the Judicial Conference of the US Supreme Court.
Areas Covered by the Amendments
definition of discoverable material;
early attention to issues relating to electronic discovery, including the format of production;
discovery of electronically stored information from sources that are not reasonably accessible;
the procedure for asserting claim of privilege or work product protection after production; and
a "safe harbor" limit on sanctions under Rule 37 for the loss of electronically stored information as a result of the routine operation of computer systems.
1. Definition of Discoverable Material
The amendments include the use of a very broad definition of what type of electronic data is discoverable: "electronically stored information." This term was added to Rules 26(a)(1), 33, and 34. Presumably, this would permit the inclusion of ESI as presently stored and as it may be kept in the future.
2. Early Attention to Electronic Discovery Issues
Rule 26(a)(1)(B) now includes ESI as a matter to be included in a party's initial disclosures, Rule 16(b)(5) adds provisions for the disclosure or discovery of electronically stored information as an item that may appropriately be included in the court's scheduling order, and Rule 26(f) added ESI to its list of issues that must be included in the meet and confer process, even going so far as to make ESI part of a discovery plan. Clearly, there is now greater emphasis on the importance of ESI in the discovery phase of a case and the need for its regulation.
3. Form of Production
Rule 34(b) now also focuses attention on the form of production of electronically stored information by permitting the requesting party to designate the way in which it is produced without specifying any single format for production. There is also a framework for resolving disputes over the form of production. In the event of an objection and failure of the requesting party to specify a format for production, the rules now place the burden on the responding party to notify the requesting party of the format in which they intend to produce the electronically stored information. The responding party can produce the data either (1) in a form in which the information is ordinarily maintained, or (2) in a reasonably usable form.
4. Rule 26(b)(2): Sources That Are Not Reasonably Accessible
Amended Rule 26(b)(2) provides the responding party with two options when faced with responding to an ESI production request based on whether the data sought is reasonably accessible or not. If the source of the ESI is not reasonably accessible because of undue burden or cost, the responding party need not comply. A motion to compel may be filed, and then the court will render a decision.
5. After-Production Retroactive Claims of Privilege/Work Product Protections
Rule 26(b)(5) now sets forth a procedure whereby a party who has produced ESI may retroactively raise claims of privilege and work product protections. The party seeking to establish the privilege or work product claim must notify the receiving parties of the claim(s) and the grounds for it. All receiving parties must return, sequester, or destroy the specified information and await a court decision as to whether the assertion of the privilege is valid.
6. "Safe Harbor"
There are protections for an employer who through routine operation and in food faith deletes electronic data. Rule 37(f) states that absent exceptional circumstances, a court may not impose sanctions on a party for failing to provide electronically stored information lost as a result of the routine, good-faith operation of an electronic information system. This amendment addresses the routine modification, overwriting, and deletion of information that is part of the normal use of ESI.
About the Author
Michael Goldfarb has been a practicing attorney in California for the last 15 years, and he is also the president of Holman HR, a nationwide provider of human resources consulting services. Michael has represented management and employers of all sizes on a variety of employment law matters. He is a sought after lecturer to business groups, non-profit associations, and universities, and has written numerous articles in the area of employment law. Michael resides with his wife Lily in Thousand Oaks, California.
Derek , Arlington, TX
I got a job through HRCrossing. It was very helpful as I could focus towards the particular listings I wanted.
Deborah , Lighthouse Point, FL
I found it really helpful as I got a couple of job leads through HRCrossing, and got my new job.
Leigh , Denver, CO
I liked the 'My hotlist' feature on HRCrossing. It was the best of the abundant of features on the site.
Mandie , Quincy, MA
HRCrossing has a large quantity of jobs which are updated very frequently--ensuring freshness.
Jennifer , St. Louis, MO
The quick search option and the advance search engine are the best options on HRCrossing. They also save a lot of time.
To compare HRCrossing with other job sites
You Have Exceptional People Skills, Strong Organizational Capabilities, are a Master at Helping Others and Deserve Approval
Top jobs are scattered on the websites of tens of thousands of companies, organizations and other job boards. It requires creativity to bring everyone together: Through research we are able put these jobs in one place and give you the ability to see a variety of jobs you would not see elsewhere.
You value harmony and are good at creating it: Use us to analyze and evaluate the jobs you are interested in collected and organized from over 50,000 websites. You are honest, creative and imaginative and deserve the best.
Benefits Manager United States-NY-Albany
BENEFITS MANAGER The Patient Care Division of Northeast Health (Albany Memorial and Samaritan Hospital) has an immediate opening for a Benefits ....
According to the Department of Labor, the field of human resources is expected to grow by as much as 22 percent from 2008 to 2018. This translates to approximately 197,000 new jobs appearing in the human resource job bank within the same time period, which is very good news, indeed, for the thousands of human resource generalists and specialists.
See Every Human Resources Job We Can Find on the Internet!
Unlike other sites, HRCrossing works for you and does not charge employers to post jobs and actually goes out and researches jobs for you. The jobs you see are the jobs we find for you and not the ones employers are paying us to post.
You Have Exceptional People Skills, Strong Organizational Capabilities, are a Master at Helping Others and Deserve Approval
Top jobs are scattered on the websites of tens of thousands of companies, organizations and other job boards. It requires creativity to bring everyone together: Through research we are able put these jobs in one place and give you the ability to see a variety of jobs you would not see elsewhere.
See all the jobs in your profession structured and efficiently organized in one place. Your honesty, ability to create harmony and people skills will all pay off when you have access to:
HR jobs from every job board we can find.
HR jobs from every newspaper classified ad we can find.
HR jobs from every specialized HR publication we can find.
HR jobs from every federal, state and local HR career page we can find.
HR jobs from every public interest, nonprofit and other career page we can find.
Tell us where to send your access instructions:
Today at HRCrossing
2,163 - Jobs found in last 24 Hours9,635 - Jobs found in last 7 Days36,633 - Total Jobs Found
Your privacy is guaranteed. We will never give out, lease, or sell your personal information.
HRCrossing - #1 Job Aggregation and Private Job-Opening Research Service — The Most Quality Jobs Anywhere
HRCrossing is the first job consolidation service in the employment industry to seek to include every job that exists and not charge employers to post jobs on its site.
HRCrossing uses sophisticated technology and manual work to comb employer websites and other job boards for jobs and bring them all to its site.
